When it comes to foundation fundraising, more isn't always better.
It's easy to get excited about a foundation with a large endowment or an impressive grantmaking history. But just because a foundation can fund your organization doesn't mean it's the right prospect.
At Contour Strategies, we believe successful foundation fundraising starts with thoughtful research, realistic expectations, and strong relationships. The goal isn't to build the longest possible prospect list. It's to identify funders whose priorities genuinely align with your work and develop a strategy for connecting with them.
Here's how to get started.
Step 1: Start With What You Know
Before searching for new foundations, look at your organization's giving history over the past three to five years.
Who has supported you? Which funders have declined requests? Are there relationships with prior funders that have lapsed, that appear worth reconnecting with?
Your strongest prospects may already know your organization. Understanding those relationships helps you identify renewal opportunities and build on existing connections.
Step 2: Look Beyond the Mission Statement
Mission alignment matters, but it's only the beginning.
When evaluating a foundation, consider:
Geography: Does the foundation fund organizations in your community?
Giving history: Has it supported similar organizations or projects?
Grant size: Are its typical awards appropriate for your funding needs?
Funding priorities: Does it support your specific program, capital project, or campaign?
Accessibility: Is there an open application process, or do you need an invitation?
Tools like Candid, foundation websites, annual reports, and publicly available tax filings can help answer these questions.
Step 3: Evaluate the Opportunity, Not Just the Funding
A $100,000 opportunity sounds wonderful, but what if the foundation only accepts applications by invitation and you have no existing relationship?
Or perhaps a $10,000 grant requires weeks of preparation, or is severely restricted to a certain kind of expense that you will have a hard time spending down.
Consider the time, effort, funding limitations, and relationship-building required alongside the potential award. A smaller, well-aligned opportunity may be a better investment of your limited resources.
Step 4: Score and Prioritize Your Prospects
Once you've identified potential funders, it's time to prioritize.
We've developed a Grant Prospect Scoring Matrix to help nonprofits evaluate opportunities across four key areas:
Mission alignment
Funding fit
Relationship potential
Application complexity and return on investment
Funder giving history
Each criterion receives a score, helping you compare prospects and determine where to focus your energy.
| Category | Criteria | Scoring Guidance | Score (0-10) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mission Alignment | How well does the funder's priorities align with the applicant’s mission and programs? |
10 – Perfect alignment; 5 – Moderate alignment; 0 – Misaligned |
|
| Funding Fit | Does the typical grant size match the program's financial need and scale? |
10 – Grant size is ideal and within the expected funding range.; 5 – Grant size is small but still useful.; 0 – Funding is either too small to justify effort or significantly beyond what’s realistic. |
|
| Funding Fit | Is this funding for a program we already have in place, desire to expand, or want to create? |
10 – We have the program in place and a plan for other funding.; 5 – We partially have the program in place and some funding.; 0 – We have neither a plan for the program or funding for it. |
|
| Relationship Potential | Existing connection or potential to build a relationship with funder? |
10 – Strong pre-existing relationship, or clear warm connection through board/staff.; 5 – No existing relationship, but opportunity exists for meaningful engagement.; 0 – Cold prospect with no access or visibility. |
|
| Application Complexity & ROI | Do I have enough time to prepare the application? |
10 – More than 6 weeks until the application deadline.; 5 – Between 4 - 6 weeks until the deadline.; 0 – Less than 4 weeks until the deadline. |
|
| Application Complexity & ROI | How difficult is the application to write? |
10 – Less than 3 hours.; 5 – Between 3-5 hours.; 0 – More than 5 hours. |
|
| Application Complexity & ROI | Time and effort required to apply versus the potential award (funding amount + strategic value) |
10 – Straightforward application process relative to potential gain.; 5 – Moderate effort required with medium potential reward.; 0 – High effort (e.g., lengthy LOI, multi-phase review) for limited gain. |
|
| Funder’s Grant History | Funder's track record of giving to my organization. |
10 – Regularly funds my organization.; 5 – Occasional funding, but not annually and not reliably.; 0 – Never given to my organization. |
|
| Funder’s Grant History | Funder's track record of giving to similar organizations or projects. |
10 – Regularly funds similar work or peer organizations.; 5 – Occasional or unclear funding in the relevant space.; 0 – No evidence of funding similar work or organizations. |
|
| SCORE | 0 |
| Priorities: | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority | Criteria | Score | Level of Effort |
| Priority 1 | Strong mission alignment, high giving capacity, existing relationship or positive engagement history. | 70+ | High |
| Priority 2 | Strong alignment, mid-level capacity, limited or new engagement. | 50 - 70 | Medium |
| Priority 3 | Lower alignment or capacity, appropriate for general or small grant strategies. | Less than 50 | Low |
| Priority 4 | High capacity and alignment, but currently no relationship—require significant cultivation. | 30 - 60 | High |
| Priority 5 | Previously supported the organization but have not engaged recently (lapsed). | 30 - 60 | Medium |
| Priority 6 | No discernible path to engagement; insufficient alignment or access. | Less than 30 | Low |
| Priority 7 | Foundations that have definitively declined and indicated no interest in future engagement | Less than 30 | Low |
Remember, a score is a starting point, not the final answer. A high-capacity foundation with no current relationship may be worth cultivating over time, even if it isn't ready for an application today.
Step 5: Build a Strategy, Not Just a Spreadsheet
Your final prospect list should guide action.
For each foundation, identify a realistic request range based on its giving history, potential connections, application deadlines, and your next step.
Some prospects will be ready for proposals. Others may need an introductory conversation, a board connection, or several months of relationship-building. That's okay! Foundation fundraising is a long-term investment.
The bottom line: Effective prospect research helps nonprofits spend less time chasing unlikely opportunities and more time building meaningful funding partnerships. A focused, thoughtful strategy will almost always serve your organization better than a lengthy list of foundation names.
